Skip to main content
← Journal

November 3, 2026 · Archipartners Design

What City Plan Reviewers Look For on Residential Permit Sets

The plan-check questions that come up again and again on additions, ADUs and remodels in the Phoenix area, and what to put on the plans so the reviewer doesn’t have to ask.

A building permit review is a conversation. You submit drawings, the city’s reviewer reads them against the adopted codes and the city’s own amendments, and anything unclear or missing comes back as a written comment. Each round of comments adds time.

The good news is that the questions are predictable. On additions, ADUs, garage conversions and remodels, the same handful of items come up again and again. Here they are, and what to put on the plans so the reviewer doesn’t have to ask.

What reviewers ask for, and what to gather first

Unpermitted work

Reviewers ask for: Existing work brought into compliance (IBC 114)

Have ready before submittal: The property's permit history, searched by address

Electrical

Reviewers ask for: A load calculation (NEC Article 220) and a panel schedule

Have ready before submittal: The existing panel's rating and a photo of the breakers

Plumbing

Reviewers ask for: Water-pipe sizing and a riser or isometric diagram

Have ready before submittal: The size of the existing water service and meter

Heating and cooling

Reviewers ask for: ACCA Manual J, Manual S and Manual D

Have ready before submittal: A settled floor plan and window sizes

The lot

Reviewers ask for: Plat building lines, easements, grading and drainage

Have ready before submittal: Recorded plat, title report or easement list, HOA guidelines

Local amendments

Reviewers ask for: The city's own changes to the national codes

Have ready before submittal: The amendments and code edition for your exact address

Existing work that was never permitted

When you apply for new work, the reviewer looks at the whole property. If the city’s records show a garage and your site plan shows a bedroom, expect a comment asking you to bring the existing work into compliance, usually under the building code’s section on violations (IBC 114, or the residential code’s equivalent).

What to do: search the property’s permit history by address before design starts. Show any unpermitted areas on the plans as existing work to be legalized, so they’re reviewed together with the new work. Expect that legalizing may mean opening some finishes so the inspector can see what’s behind them.

Electrical load and the panel

An ADU, an EV charger, a pool or a larger AC unit all add electrical load. Reviewers commonly ask for a load calculation under NEC Article 220 and a panel schedule that lists every circuit, including the new ones.

What to do: get the existing panel’s rating and a photo of the breakers early. If the calculation shows you need a bigger service, ask your city whether that size of service needs a design sealed by an Arizona-registered electrical engineer. Find that out before submittal, not after.

Water supply sizing and plumbing vents

A fixture layout isn’t the whole plumbing plan. For new bathrooms and ADUs especially, reviewers ask for a water-pipe sizing calculation (the plumbing code’s Appendix E method is common) and a riser or isometric diagram showing how each fixture is vented.

What to do: confirm the size of the existing water service and meter. If the ADU tees off the main house line, show the calculation that proves it’s enough.

Heating and cooling calculations

For new homes, additions and ADUs with their own system, many departments ask for ACCA Manual J (the load), Manual S (equipment selection) and Manual D (duct design). A note that says the HVAC is by others usually isn’t accepted.

What to do: run the calculations once the floor plan and window sizes are settled, and make sure the equipment shown on the plans matches the Manual S selection.

The lot itself

Zoning setbacks are only the start. A recorded plat can carry stricter building lines, easements can block an otherwise legal footprint, and many cities want a grading and drainage plan for a new home. HOA rules aren’t enforced by the city, but they can stop a project anyway.

What to do: before design, gather the recorded plat, a title report or list of easements, and the HOA’s architectural guidelines if there is an HOA.

Local amendments

Every Valley city adopts the national codes with its own changes. Garage and outdoor receptacle rules, flood-zone requirements and energy-code options vary from Phoenix to Tempe to Gilbert, and a county island follows the county, not the nearest city.

What to do: look up the amendments for the exact jurisdiction your address sits in, and the code edition it has adopted.

The takeaway

Most plan-check comments aren’t surprises. They’re the same questions, asked for good reasons. A set that answers them up front, with the code analysis, the calculations and the lot research done, gives the reviewer what they need.

We do drafting and permit plans for ADUs and casitas, additions and remodels in Arizona. Every set opens with a code-analysis sheet, and if the city flags an error in our drawings, we fix it free. Ask for a quote.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

  • What do city plan reviewers ask about most on additions, ADUs and remodels?

    The same few things come up again and again: existing work that was never permitted, electrical load and the panel, water supply sizing and plumbing vents, heating and cooling calculations, and the lot itself — setbacks, plat building lines, easements and drainage.

  • What happens if my house has work that was never permitted?

    Expect a comment asking you to bring it into compliance. Search the property’s permit history by address before design starts, and show unpermitted areas on the plans as existing work to be legalized so they’re reviewed with the new work. Legalizing may mean opening some finishes so the inspector can see what’s behind them.

  • Do I need an electrical load calculation for an ADU or EV charger?

    Reviewers commonly ask for one. An ADU, an EV charger, a pool or a larger AC unit all add load, so expect a calculation under NEC Article 220 and a panel schedule listing every circuit, including the new ones.

  • Will a note saying “HVAC by others” be accepted?

    Usually not. For new homes, additions and ADUs with their own system, many departments ask for ACCA Manual J (the load), Manual S (equipment selection) and Manual D (duct design), and the equipment on the plans should match the Manual S selection.

  • Are the code rules the same in every Phoenix-area city?

    No. Every Valley city adopts the national codes with its own changes, so garage and outdoor receptacle rules, flood-zone requirements and energy-code options vary from Phoenix to Tempe to Gilbert. A county island follows the county, not the nearest city.

Have a project that fits this conversation? Send a sketch and a sentence.

Begin a project →

We reply within one business day.

What City Plan Reviewers Look For on Residential Permit Sets · Archipartners Design